Autonerdz Home Autonerdz FAQ User’s Comments Autonerdz Events Autonerdz Store Contact Autonerdz

Autonerdz forums

 
  Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register
Autonerdz - Since 2000, North America's Authority on PicoScope
 
  HomeHelpSearch Member Map Event CalendarRegisterLogin  
 
Pages: 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8
firstlook (Read 150,446 times)
mwebb
Senior Member
***
Offline



Posts: 162

Gender: male
Re: firstlook
Reply #60 - Jul 3rd, 2007 at 10:08pm
 
and again - maybe slower ....
Back to top
 
mwebb  
IP Logged
 
mwebb
Senior Member
***
Offline



Posts: 162

Gender: male
Re: firstlook
Reply #61 - Jul 3rd, 2007 at 10:12pm
 
now it will not have the ani gif , just gif , i have to learn how to control these things

after calibrating running compression overlay waveform to known 720 degrees in the waveform ...

anyway if nothing else , you can see very clearly how to determine where TDC is based in the time of the FLS e pressure transducer ,  just set the exhaust valve opening event to match a previously recorded running compression waveform from the same engine and where TDC is is where it is - of course the spark waveform will be before it -  the spark waveform should be before it the number of degrees shown in scan data -    but it wont be because of the delay in the pressure transducer so ....

you could position the running compression waveform based on spark advance value in scan data to see when the events are actualy happening in relation to spark or CKP or ....
using the vertical cursors measuring in degrees [ calibrated to known 720 degrees in the waveform ]  to set the exact position   
Back to top
 
mwebb  
IP Logged
 
mwebb
Senior Member
***
Offline



Posts: 162

Gender: male
Re: firstlook
Reply #62 - Jul 15th, 2007 at 9:45pm
 

this is out of the though sequence here ... but it relates to the FLSe transducer delay , or the MAF sensor delay or both .
this shows misfire in cylinder 3 as per the FLSe waveform , dead injector , no biggie .
   but the misfire is also shown by a hiccup in the MAF sensor waveform for cylinder 2 intake pulse .
 
   to me , a biggie that i will remember and watch for .
Back to top
 
mwebb  
IP Logged
 
Rick Hill
LSD Guide
Picogroup
*****
Offline


Deceased

Posts: 660

Gender: male
Re: firstlook
Reply #63 - Jul 19th, 2007 at 4:42pm
 
Here are a couple of fls captures on an 04 f 150 5.4 with a vct system. This engine is very sick and surprisingly only one cylinder has no compression according to a relative compression test and it's not where you might think it would be looking at the fls wave forms.  One of these captures is in the intake at about 510 rpm and the other is in the exhaust at about 1760 rpm. See if they will tell you anything about the condition of this motor or is there any useful info there at all.  I will add these in psdata so you can manipulate them and they were done on version 6.06 if it matters.
    Here is one from the exhaust.
Back to top
« Last Edit: Jul 19th, 2007 at 5:03pm by Rick Hill »  

Rick Hill
 
IP Logged
 
Rick Hill
LSD Guide
Picogroup
*****
Offline


Deceased

Posts: 660

Gender: male
Re: firstlook
Reply #64 - Jul 19th, 2007 at 4:43pm
 
Here is the one from the intake running at about 510 rpm.
Back to top
 

Rick Hill
 
IP Logged
 
mwebb
Senior Member
***
Offline



Posts: 162

Gender: male
Re: firstlook
Reply #65 - Jul 19th, 2007 at 9:20pm
 
Quote:
Here are a couple of fls captures on an 04 f 150 5.4 with a vct system. This engine is very sick and surprisingly only one cylinder has no compression according to a relative compression test and it's not where you might think it would be looking at the fls wave forms.  One of these captures is in the intake at about 510 rpm and the other is in the exhaust at about 1760 rpm. See if they will tell you anything about the condition of this motor or is there any useful info there at all.  I will add these in psdata so you can manipulate them and they were done on version 6.06 if it matters.
     Here is one from the exhaust.

---------------------------------------------------------------
for the record , this doesnt work well when there is a wave running through the waveforms ,  here i ignore the wave , but that is a bad idea    but that is the only sample presented . 
engine rpm is not stable , exhaust events are not evenly spaced and should occur every 90 degrees  .
               720 degrees  divided by 8 cylinders .  1 exhaust valve opens every 90 degrees .   

              and i need a much huger sample to pluck a stable 720 degrees  from.... but  working with what i have here  i get the following     , 
     i dont see a misfire signature here and i dont see the effects  of the o2 puff following a misfire .... but i can line up the "combustion power " event   connected to the exhaust when there should be a lesser pressure dip than there really is ...
     so based on what is presented i see leaking exhaust valve on the fourth cylinder in the fireing order relative to the spark shown .

but that is ignoring the effects of that wave .... i need a bigger sample---    100ms psdata stable at hot idle with trans in gear brake on if possible . 
Back to top
« Last Edit: Jul 19th, 2007 at 10:10pm by mwebb »  
mwebb  
IP Logged
 
mwebb
Senior Member
***
Offline



Posts: 162

Gender: male
Re: firstlook
Reply #66 - Jul 19th, 2007 at 9:25pm
 
for the record , this doesnt work well when there is a wave running through the waveforms ,  here i ignore the wave , but that is a bad idea    but that is the only sample presented . 
   engine rpm is not stable , exhaust events are not evenly spaced and should occur every 90 degrees  .

             and i need a much huger sample to pluck a stable 720 degrees  from.... but  working with what i have here  i get the following     , 
     i dont see a misfire signature here and i dont see the effects  of the o2 puff following a misfire .... but i can line up the "combustion power " event   connected to the exhaust when there should be a lesser pressure dip than there really is ... 
     so based on what is presented i see leaking exhaust valve on the fourth cylinder in the fireing order relative to the spark shown . 

but that is ignoring the effects of that wave .... i need a bigger sample---    100ms psdata stable at hot idle with trans in gear brake on if possible .

for those who prefer a stable gif 
Back to top
« Last Edit: Jul 19th, 2007 at 10:06pm by mwebb »  
mwebb  
IP Logged
 
Rick Hill
LSD Guide
Picogroup
*****
Offline


Deceased

Posts: 660

Gender: male
Re: firstlook
Reply #67 - Jul 20th, 2007 at 10:16am
 
Hi Michael
     I agree those captures are hard to make much of. You may well be right about that exhaust valve leak at the fourth  in the order . I'll check that before it's gets torn down. The firing order here is 13726548.  I can't really slow the engine down and get a more stable capture over a longer period of time. If I let it idle  that wave as you call it running through the wave form will get like the intake capture and I'll have to raise the voltage scale on the scope to the point that you'll no longer see any individual pulses or it will run right off the screen.  It becomes extremely unstable at slower speeds. Did you look at the intake capture and notice how the wave running through the wave form is like the inverse of what you see in the exhaust?  I'm pretty much thinking about what I might see in these wave forms when the valve timing is way out of sync with the piston position.  The only thing that makes me rethink that  is the ignition and injector timing is right according to the crank sensor and the fact that I show eight cylinders in a relative compression test. I think if one cam was 360 out of time I would only see four  cylinders in a relative compression test. The cams are synced together so if one is out of time both are out of time. There was the possibility of one being 360 off but the eight pulses in the compression test kind of ruled that out I think. I can pretty positively say at least one intake valve is wide open or close to it when the piston comes to tdc compression. From the fls wave forms  it looks to be the 4th in the firing order but from the relative compression capture it would logically be the 7th in the firing order.
    Thanks for taking a look at that and giving me your opinion on what you see in there. I know it takes a bit of your time to look through those captures and annotate them as you've done. I know I spend a bit of time looking through them a number of times after I've looked through them the first time for anything that just obviously stands out. I notice it looks like you figure there is a pretty good delay in the fls reporting when compared to an electrical signal. I found about a 3 ms delay in my pv 500 but I've never checked the fls for delay. I have gone under the assumption that it was at least quite a bit faster than my pv 500  and haven't figured on the delay much when looking at these wave forms.  I believe it's a piezo device rather than a pressure transducer and assumed it to be faster to report. Do you figure the delay to be about the same as your pressure transducer? I guess I should check it and find out what the delay actually is so I can figure that in there as well.
 Here is a relative compression capture  to give you a little more info about why those fls waves may look like they do with the blue being starter current and the red being #1 primary.
Back to top
 

Rick Hill
 
IP Logged
 
mwebb
Senior Member
***
Offline



Posts: 162

Gender: male
Re: firstlook
Reply #68 - Jul 20th, 2007 at 4:17pm
 
before you open it up ....
please get a running compression waveform from each bank and 1 from the cylinder with no compression .  psdata    50ms    try to get them all at the same rpm .   
i can annotate them pretty quickly , and i can stack them up to see cam timing issues .

also , FLS in the oil stick , to see if there is a vacuum leak into the crankcase and to see if there are bad piston rings somewhere .
      FLS will pick up vibrations from engine contact so wrap it in rags or whatever to isolate it as best you can .  i hang the FLS from the hood latch so it doesnt touch anything . 
include MAF signal set on AC coupling to partially  fill the screen
sync on something , #1 primary is ok .
psdata 100ms or 50ms


i learn by doing this stuff .   
Back to top
 
mwebb  
IP Logged
 
Wilf
Super Nerd
Picogroup
*****
Offline


Never too old to learn

Posts: 814

Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada, Manitoba, Canada
Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
Manitoba
Canada

Gender: male
Re: firstlook
Reply #69 - Jul 20th, 2007 at 4:52pm
 
A lot of the time (always) mechanical integrity is easier to see with the engine cranking and not running.
I use two FLS 100 testers and do intake and exhaust at the same time with a sync.
That way you don't have to deal with any turbulance caused by the misfire.
That is my 2 cents
Take it for what it is worth
Here is an example of a toyota

Wilf
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Rick Hill
LSD Guide
Picogroup
*****
Offline


Deceased

Posts: 660

Gender: male
Re: firstlook
Reply #70 - Jul 20th, 2007 at 5:56pm
 
Michael
The truck is still laying around here so I'll see about getting those running compression waves.  Maybe I can do that in the morning. I just got a 16x1.5 compression test adapter for it yesterday afternoon.
    This thing will not run at a steady rpm at idle but I'll see what I can do. It only has 6-8 inhg of vacume and that fluctuates about 4 inhg up and down when it tries to idle. If this  wasn't computer controlled it wouldn't even run with out making some major adjustments.

Wilf
    Thanks for that suggestion on using the fls for a cranking test you make a very good point. I don't have two fls' but I'll take a look see with the one I have..
Back to top
 

Rick Hill
 
IP Logged
 
mwebb
Senior Member
***
Offline



Posts: 162

Gender: male
Re: firstlook
Reply #71 - Jul 21st, 2007 at 7:30am
 
yes of course , Wilf's suggestions should give up the problem and it will eliminate the "wave" .
you may want to  attempt to AC couple the MAF sensor signal with FLSe   for the intake  pulses waveform.  and sync it to something .

still i would like the running compression waveform s , and idle with FLS in the oil stick with maf ac coupled , just for reference ... please o please .

i have to leave a note on the laptop remember the cranking tests .... i am not getting any younger 
Back to top
 
mwebb  
IP Logged
 
mwebb
Senior Member
***
Offline



Posts: 162

Gender: male
Re: firstlook
Reply #72 - Jul 22nd, 2007 at 11:19am
 
here is the Intake FLSi  waveform overlayed on top of the FLSe waveform .  if these patterns are consistently the same ????   
i can overlay the cranking waveforms to verify the answer to the question .

i would like running compression waveforms for cyl 7 2 6 and one other ... for reference please o please .
Back to top
 
mwebb  
IP Logged
 
Rick Hill
LSD Guide
Picogroup
*****
Offline


Deceased

Posts: 660

Gender: male
Re: firstlook
Reply #73 - Jul 22nd, 2007 at 12:55pm
 
Hi Michael
      I will get those wave forms but I got side tracked yesterday with Dogs and didn't get them done. Friend of mine was running a bear south of here for the game and fish folks with my tracking collars on his dogs. I have my name ph number and address on my tracking collars so all day long I kept getting calls about lost dogs showing up in folks yards. Most folks don't understand those collars are radio transmitters so they don't know what to think when you tell them that the dogs owner will be along shortly. I ended up taking a trip south to help round up dogs. In the old days these dogs had good homing instincts because they always just ran loose on a fellas property and went where they wanted but these days they spend all their time in a kennel so on a hunt after a couple days on track they get hungry and go to the first sign of civilization rather than home. The homing instinct has been kind of bred out of them so to speak.

     I see you and I are roughly on the same page with those wave forms. I came up with the peak in that intake wave being at about 442 degrees after #1 firing event but I also came up with 442 degrees after the firing event in the exhaust wave as being about 42ms after the firing event  you show that point as being a little earlier than 442 degrees. I still tend to think there is a valve timing problem here as well. I guess we'll know more about that as soon as I get those captures done.
     Time wise what do you figure the delay to be with the fls?  Thats something I'm still unsure of.
Back to top
 

Rick Hill
 
IP Logged
 
mwebb
Senior Member
***
Offline



Posts: 162

Gender: male
Re: firstlook
Reply #74 - Jul 22nd, 2007 at 6:33pm
 
Quote:
Hi Michael
      I will get those wave forms but I got side tracked yesterday with Dogs and didn't get them done. Friend of mine was running a bear south of here for the game and fish folks with my tracking collars on his dogs. I have my name ph number and address on my tracking collars so all day long I kept getting calls about lost dogs showing up in folks yards. Most folks don't understand those collars are radio transmitters so they don't know what to think when you tell them that the dogs owner will be along shortly. I ended up taking a trip south to help round up dogs. In the old days these dogs had good homing instincts because they always just ran loose on a fellas property and went where they wanted but these days they spend all their time in a kennel so on a hunt after a couple days on track they get hungry and go to the first sign of civilization rather than home. The homing instinct has been kind of bred out of them so to speak.

     I see you and I are roughly on the same page with those wave forms. I came up with the peak in that intake wave being at about 442 degrees after #1 firing event but I also came up with 442 degrees after the firing event in the exhaust wave as being about 42ms after the firing event  you show that point as being a little earlier than 442 degrees. I still tend to think there is a valve timing problem here as well. I guess we'll know more about that as soon as I get those captures done.
     Time wise what do you figure the delay to be with the fls?  Thats something I'm still unsure of.

there is no rush , i just would like the waveform before it gets dissassembled if possible 

if you get scan data timing value , and a running compression waveform , i can position the exhaust waveform where it should be relative to the spark waveform , same with the intake . 
you can see the values in degrees as valves open and close with TDCs and BDCs .  you can compare those measured values to Ford specification and see if there is valve timing problem s . [and CMP CKP ?]
     
            and as Wilf suggested , cranking FLSe with MAF signal on AC coupling synced to something.

i would concentrate on that spike in the intake if i were doing this , then the 2 misfires .

  the dogs have priority.
Back to top
 
mwebb  
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8